It's ok.
I order the Mascara on a subscription because I wanted to try it. I received it for 3 months and decided it was ok but for the price I decided to cancel the subscription. It made my eye lashes itchy after a few hours ?
CITY BEAUTY · CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES
Beyond Mascara
Reviews
Read what customers say, with 64 original reviews and ratings collected on CityBeauty.com.
Updated September 2026 · About these reviews
View product on City BeautyWhat customers are saying
Original words. All star ratings.
6 reviews · Featured order starts with positive reviews and includes four- and three-star experiences where available. Detail and verified purchases help determine the order. All ratings remain available.
It's one of my faves!
I really love mascara, as well as the growth serum..I do find it does start flaking after I've used the tube for awhile, I also think that it is a little pricey..
One of the better mascaras that I have used
It goes on smooth. Does have a few clumps but not like others that I have used. It stays on and doesn't smear under my eyes. It seems to stay on all day. I do use a mascara remover to remove at night. My face cleaner doesn't remove it like some others that I have used.. this is definitely going to be my go to product. The only improvement would be if it could slowly dye my lashes so I wouldn't need to wear mascara everyday. 😏
I really like this product but...
I really like this mascara but I wish it came in a waterproof formula. I swim --a lot-- and occasionally I have to use eye drops. I like to use waterproof mascara for those days when my eyes are drenched either in pool water or eye drops. The wand is really nice get a good coating on my lashes without clumping.
All mascara comes with a few issues... clumps
Yes, it does work, but no one has said anything about the flaking. I could not use this if in a rush because little black flakes/clumbs can be seen hanging on my lashes and around my eyes. It takes me some time to comb them out and remove them. I don't know if I'd recommend it without disclosing the issue.
Good mascara
It goes on well and looks good, doesn't clump. It does flake a little.
Ratings reflect all reviews for this product in the September 4, 2026 store export. Verified buyer badges reflect the store’s purchase-verification field. Individual results vary.