Beyond Mascara
I purchased this product because I love the City Lips. I was disappointed that the mascara took 3 coats to the same coverage as 1 coat of the 2 other brands that I have previously purchased. I requested a return label.
CITY BEAUTY · CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES
Beyond Mascara
Reviews
Read what customers say, with 64 original reviews and ratings collected on CityBeauty.com.
Updated September 2026 · About these reviews
View product on City BeautyWhat customers are saying
Original words. All star ratings.
4 reviews · Featured order starts with positive reviews and includes four- and three-star experiences where available. Detail and verified purchases help determine the order. All ratings remain available.
Didn't work for me
I had high hopes for this mascara after reading the reviews. When I tried to use it I had a lot of problems with it clumping. I ended up replacing it with another brand. My experience with City Beauty was a disappointment, especially considering the cost.
Still searching…
Was hoping this would be the holy grail of mascara. It was clumpy and it left the dreaded undereye black shadow. Will be continuing my search.
Not my favorite, clumbs and doesn not last
This mascara tends to clump almost every time no matter what I try. It also comes off after about 5 hours so does not last through the whole day.
Ratings reflect all reviews for this product in the September 4, 2026 store export. Verified buyer badges reflect the store’s purchase-verification field. Individual results vary.