CITY BEAUTY CUSTOMER REVIEWS & PRODUCT RATINGS
CITY BEAUTYREVIEWSShop City Beauty

CITY BEAUTY · CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES

Beyond Mascara
Reviews

Read what customers say, with 64 original reviews and ratings collected on CityBeauty.com.

Updated September 2026 · About these reviews

4.7out of 5

64 customer reviews

View product on City Beauty

What customers are saying

Original words. All star ratings.

64 reviews · Featured order starts with positive reviews and includes four- and three-star experiences where available. Detail and verified purchases help determine the order. All ratings remain available.

Best mascara

This mascara goes on so well and never smudges. I have sparse thin lashes and this definitely makes them look fuller. My lashes have also gotten healthier since using this so it does feel like it nourishes as well

G
Gena B. Verified buyer

This is my favorite...

This is my favorite mascara. The tube lasts a long time so I feel it is worth the price - I always try to buy it when there is a sale.

D
Debbie O. Verified buyer

It's ok.

I order the Mascara on a subscription because I wanted to try it. I received it for 3 months and decided it was ok but for the price I decided to cancel the subscription. It made my eye lashes itchy after a few hours ?

J
Joanie L.

A Rich Experience

Beyond mascara is a rich black that does not clump. It makes my lashes look full and long, and leaves them in better condition than before use.

D
Diane C. Verified buyer
City Beauty’s response

Hello Diane! Beyond Mascara sounds like it's exceeded your expectations, rich black color, no clumping, and healthier-looking lashes to boot. Thank you for the detailed review!

This product is everything it says it is! I took a chance and so glad I did! No clumps, I can wear this everyday! LOVE IT!

R
Rhonda F. Verified buyer

Beyond Mascara

I purchased this product because I love the City Lips. I was disappointed that the mascara took 3 coats to the same coverage as 1 coat of the 2 other brands that I have previously purchased. I requested a return label.

L
Lori Q.

I was drawn to try this mascara because of its beneficial ingredients to lashes. Its very good and not difficult to temove gently.

N
Nancy W. Verified buyer

This is the best mascara ive ever used. Makes my lashes look long and beautiful. Not to mention its good for your lashes

L
Lindy B. Verified buyer

Awedome

This is my favorite mascara! It stands out and wants to be seen!

J
Jane S. Verified buyer

It's one of my faves!

I really love mascara, as well as the growth serum..I do find it does start flaking after I've used the tube for awhile, I also think that it is a little pricey..

L
Lisa

I love this mascara

D
Debbie J. Verified buyer

Improves your lashes.

I have used Beyond Mascara for years. Everyone in a while I have tried other mascaras but I always come back to a beyond Mascara. I have blonde lashes and this mascara makes them look thicker and longer. And it helps your lashes. I highly recommend Beyond Mascara!

V
Valerie A M.

Worth the hype

I love this mascara! I wasn't expecting it to be this good. It makes my lashes long and also lifted. And doesn't smudge! Works well alone and also under my tubing mascara. Impressed.

N
NATASHA V.

Outstanding Mascara

I had seen some YouTube influencers rave about this mascara, so I thought I would try it for myself. I like it very much as it truly makes my lashes appear longer and fuller. I have already purchased a backup and plan to continue using it because it has become my favorite mascara. I would absolutely recommend giving it a try for yourself.

C
Cindy F.

Didn't work for me

I had high hopes for this mascara after reading the reviews. When I tried to use it I had a lot of problems with it clumping. I ended up replacing it with another brand. My experience with City Beauty was a disappointment, especially considering the cost.

A
Alexis

Favorite Mascara

This has become my new favorite mascara. I just ordered my second tube since I am so pleased with this product. First it is long lasting. Not only does it stay on all day but the tube itself lasts after months of usage. Next is how easy it is to apply. Very fluid for both top and bottom lashes. But best of all is that it does not clump and removes well after wearing. So happy to finally find a mascara that looks great and is so easy to use.

P
Pamela R.

Wonderful mascara

I really like Beyond Mascara. It makes my little lashes longer and doesn't shrink down after a few minutes as so many other brands do. I will definitely be reordering again!

M
Margaret

Awesome Beyond Mascara!

I've been using Beyond Mascara for several years and will never use anything else. My lashes are thick and long. No other mascara can restore your lashes like Beyond Mascara.

M
Marilyn S.

Favorite mascara by far

I've tried several different mascaras the last few years with mixed results - either not enough oomph or too much. City mascara has been head and shoulders above the rest. Separates my lashes perfectly and gives length and volume without being clumpy. I'm a fan!

S
Suzanne K.

My new best friend!

I have been using the Lash serum for a little while now due to severe loss and not being able to even think about mascara. As I noticed a thickening and growth spurt right away I decided to try Beyond mascara and was so happy I did! I feel like a new woman again! I no longer have to be embarrassed with the big gaps and clumps of mascara! Using this til I die! Lol!

C
Cobette

Ratings reflect all reviews for this product in the September 4, 2026 store export. Verified buyer badges reflect the store’s purchase-verification field. Individual results vary.

Explore more customer experiences