Lip liner ok
Nice color but too hard. Difficult to apply.
CITY BEAUTY · CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES
City Lips Defining Liner
Reviews
Read what customers say, with 49 original reviews and ratings collected on CityBeauty.com.
Updated September 2026 · About these reviews
View product on City BeautyWhat customers are saying
Original words. All star ratings.
49 reviews · Featured order starts with positive reviews and includes four- and three-star experiences where available. Detail and verified purchases help determine the order. All ratings remain available.
Wanted to love it, but...
I just received this lip liner in willow and while I love the color I found the product very dry and hard to apply - not smooth at all. The tip broke off during my first use which is disappointing. 3 Stars for the color.
Very dry
Was too dry. Very hard to even draw on my lips. Tried once and was so bad never used again.
Does stay put
I did like this liner but as a personal preference I like a linear that is more creamy and blends well. My CB liner stays where I put it.
breaks
if the liner is just alittle amout rolled out it breaks off when using. 😭 unfortunately it doesn't stay on very long either. I wanted this to be better than my CVS liner, but it's not.
Beautiful color, disappointing product
I had high hopes for this lip liner. The color is beautiful and it looks nice on, but the quality of the liner point is poor. It breaks off each time I used it, even as I tried to just barely have a very small point. It looks nice, but didn't last any longer than any other lip liner.
Disappointed
The color is fine but the product breaks when used, even when it's only extended little. I generally like City Beauty a lot so this is a surprise.
Color not as pictured
I ordered the Blush and was disappointed as it was much darker than indicated.
City Beauty’s response
Hi Karla, thank you for sharing this feedback. Ee're sorry to hear the shade wasn't what you expected. Colour can appear differently depending on lighting and screen settings, and we understand how disappointing that can be. Our customer support team would be happy to help review your order. Please reach out to [email protected] or call 1-800-347-1558.
Disappointed
I was very disappointed with the amount of actual liner in applicator.
Ratings reflect all reviews for this product in the September 4, 2026 store export. Verified buyer badges reflect the store’s purchase-verification field. Individual results vary.