The color ran in to my lines above my lips. Other colors ive bought have not

LIP CARE · CUSTOMER EXPERIENCES
City Lips
Reviews
Plumping lip gloss. Read what customers say, with 2,247 original reviews and ratings collected on CityBeauty.com.
Updated September 2026 · About these reviews
Review analysis · City Lips FAQs · Read customer reviews
View product on City BeautyWhat customers are saying
Original words. All star ratings.
244 reviews · Featured order starts with positive reviews and includes four- and three-star experiences where available. Detail and verified purchases help determine the order. All ratings remain available.
This product does nothing and was a horrible waste of money. It doesn't even hydrate let alone add volume.
There was no lip plumping in this lip gloss whatsoever, ZERO. Just s complete lie and wsist of money.
I cant tell any difference at all. So so disappointed. Dont even want to give one star.
I am not happy. See no chanhe whatsoever in lips after applying. Please advise as to how i should ship back and receive a refund.
It's just a sticky lipgloss! It had absolutely NO tingle or plump. I don't recommend. Very disappointing.
Was nothing but thick lip gloss that had NO affect. Mild irritation around the lip turning red. Was that the plump ??
I have been faithfully using this product and I have seen not even the slightest change. Very dist
Smells musty like it's expired. Had to throw it away because it smelled like wet mold.
There was zero plump just a tiny tingle when you put it on. Its more an overpriced lipgloss. Just a lipglosss is not what I thought I was purchasing.
Iam wasting my money with product it looks good on the picture but if you use it it is so sticky. I dont like it
No plumping at all. It does moisturize good but does not plump like they show....
I didn't see anything different from this lip gloss than any other gloss that costs much less.
Does absolutely nothing. Not even worth the time to put it on, let alone the $35 for a basic lip gloss.
I did not notice any difference. I think its very sticky. I am so sad it didnt do what it promised. Waste of money.
Just a regular lip gloss . . . does not plump up lips and therefore doesn't live up to "the hype " ! Very disappointed
Its very moisturizing but it doesnt do more than that. So disappointing. I can get the same thing for 10 bucks!!!!
Honestly, doesn't seem like anything, but just regular old lip gloss. Definitely not worth the price.
Does not work as advertised. There was no tingling and no plumping of my lips.
Very disappointed. Its not a plumper and its very sticky. Not at all what i was expecting.
Ratings reflect all reviews for this product in the September 4, 2026 store export. Verified buyer badges reflect the store’s purchase-verification field. Individual results vary.